kicker rankings
kicker rankings
Neither rivals nor scout has reviewed any kickers or punters that I am aware of.
The kicker rankings for Hopkins and Tausch came from Chris Sailer, who is probably more accurate than Rivals or Scout for kickers anyway.
I agree that we have to very good k/p commitments. Chris Sailor bases he's rankings on the kickers results at the camps that he runs. Like any person, you miss one kick at 30yds, but you were making 60 yarders all camp. The same kid who has a great talent, will be ranked 31 of 50. Then the results are put on recruiting and kicking websites and that same kicker may have to walk-on, because of one kick.
You can go to prokicker.com, Chris's website, and see that he does attract great talent. He does the same completion in 30 cities. I would bet that Chris is a great coach and judge of talent. I wouldn't take this as the bible.
I was also a 1994-95 high school 1st team All- American and ranked the best kicker at camps. The year I was All-American I made 1of 8 fieldgoals, the other 7 were blocked as I was on a 3and7 team. It was going to camps, sending every school my tapes, and they were able to see the whole picture. I would say the rankings should be more objective.
Kevin Kopka Notre Dame kicker 1995-99.