Tate, Floyd, or Samardzija

[Riddickulous]

who knows what the 2010 version of Floyd will bring.

Pain.

 

[kmoose]

I am saying the punishment did not fit the crime

Really? What is suitable punishment, for lying to an NCAA investigator?

 

[jason_h537]

Really? What is suitable punishment, for lying to an NCAA investigator?

How about a few games. He lied about talking to Deion Sanders becuase he is a college kid who does not wanna get in trouble in front of the NCAA. They took away an entire season. He didnt lie about taking money, living in a boosters house, ttalking to an agent, getting free clothes or cars, he didnt punch an opposing player, rape a girl. Let the kid at least play his last game

 

[DKSchrute]

Give me Floyd for a full season, healthy.
He played in 7 games and his stats would be impressive for a full season.

 

[kmoose]

How about a few games. He lied about talking to Deion Sanders becuase he is a college kid who does not wanna get in trouble in front of the NCAA. They took away an entire season. He didnt lie about taking money, living in a boosters house, ttalking to an agent, getting free clothes or cars, he didnt punch an opposing player, rape a girl. Let the kid at least play his last game

In the real world, when you lie to investigators of any type, there are generally very severe consequences. I don't care why he lied, he lied. Going in front of NCAA investigators should be every bit as serious, to these kids, as going in front of a judge in a court of law. Would you encourage them to lie in a court of law, as long as it wasn't "something serious"?

 

[jason_h537]

In the real world, when you lie to investigators of any type, there are generally very severe consequences. I don't care why he lied, he lied. Going in front of NCAA investigators should be every bit as serious, to these kids, as going in front of a judge in a court of law. Would you encourage them to lie in a court of law, as long as it wasn't "something serious"?

in a court of law he would have legal counsel

 

[philipm31]

The South Carolina legend.

They retired his number a little while back, I may be biased having lived in South Carolina for several years. But hes one of the most complete WR's I've ever seen, no flaws at all.

I think that you are way biased, honestly. I mean, do you honestly believe he was better than Sterling Sharpe?? Just breaking records don't make one a better WR...although that does not hurt. Still, though, if I could have any one WR in ND history, it would be Tim Brown and I don't think he owns a single receiving record anymore at ND.

But I voted for Shark because he was just an unbelievable red zone target.

 

[BGIF]

in a court of law he would have legal counsel

yawn!

 

[BillyIrish]

Tate is great, but Floyd is the answer.

 

[IRISHinKC]

Tate is great, but Floyd is the answer.

I hope so!