NBC Makes a Change in the Booth

GoshenGipper

Rest In Peace
Messages
7,946
Reaction score
394
The Blue-Gray Sky

Although announced back on August 7th, it slipped our notice (and the notice of most ND fans) that one half of NBC's game day crew was being replaced. According to this NBC press release, Tom Hammond will not be not be calling the Notre Dame - Georgia Tech game. Instead, Bob Papa, the play-by-play voice of the New York Giants, will work the game with regular Pat Haden.

Hammond will be in Japan when toe meets leather on September 1st, covering the IAAF World Championships in Osaka, as a run up to the Beijing Olympics. Sideline reporter Lewis Johnson is going with him. I originally thought Hammond and Johnson were just going to work this one event and then be back at Notre Dame in time for Michigan State. But if you keep reading the press release linked above, it mentions Papa on the broadcast for the MSU game as well. From what I can tell, there isn't another Olympic event during that time frame that NBC is covering, so maybe Hammond is gone from the Dome for good.

Replacing Lewis Johnson in the role of sideline reporter is Alex Flanagan, who works for the NFL Network and more recently worked the sideline of the Texas-Tech - Minnesota Insight bowl game. It's now her turn to ask softball questions at halftime that Charlie will answer sarcastically on his way to the locker room.

Back to Bob Papa. Notre Dame Football is the next distinguishment for Papa, who in addition to being the radio "voice of the Giants," has a glittering resume. He handles many broadcasting duties for Westwood One radio covering a variety of sports, including anchoring the Masters and the U.S. Open radio broadcasts, and doing play by play for the NCAA basketball tournament. He's the blow-by-blow ringside announcer for HBO Boxing. He's also got a long history with NBC, covering a variety of Olympic events for the network dating back to the '92 summer games, and handling the play by play for NBC's coverage of Arena Football.

Here's an audio clip of Bob Papa talking Giants football.

You know, I never thought Tom Hammond was a bad announcer. He was smooth and professional, and never embarrassed himself or Notre Dame. But there was something particularly bland about his play by play. You'd never know it was Notre Dame football judging by his tone and demeanor; he might as well have been covering Olympic figure skating. His style and manner exemplifies what he is: a network journeyman dutifully covering his assignment. Football, on the other hand, demands character and passion. We like our football coverage to be a little more Howard Cosell, and a little less network talking head. Hopefully Bob Papa will fit the bill.
 
G

GreenNGold

Guest
I'm sure Papa will do a wonderful job doing the play-by-play, but honestly, I'd rather have Hammond doing it.

What I associate with Notre Dame football, at least for television, is Tom's own particular style doing the games. It'll be tough to get acclimated to a new voice calling the game.

But I do enjoy Haden's analysis, so that softens the blow a bit.
 

onenybrother

The Giver of Articles
Messages
1,404
Reaction score
151
Being a Diehard Giant Fan, I have to say PaPa is a goos choice. He very knowledgeable, and calls a good game. But I hope Tommy comes back.
 

LOVEMYIRISH

old timer
Messages
5,125
Reaction score
409
Being a Diehard Giant Fan, I have to say PaPa is a goos choice. He very knowledgeable, and calls a good game. But I hope Tommy comes back.

I am not familiar with the new guy, but I have heard good things. Hammond did a great job though.
 
C

CLEARWALL

Guest
I hate the Giants, so hopefully he doesn't make it obvious his history. I think i'd go batty if he has a Guido accent. I cant stand listening to Yankee broadcasters for exactly that reason. *shudder*
 
Messages
11,214
Reaction score
377
I wish NBC would go with "ND" guys. Maybe Allen Pinkett or someone like him. I can't stand having Haden in the booth. I just think he likes seeing ND lose (because he's a U$C guy). Go Irish!
 

GoshenGipper

Rest In Peace
Messages
7,946
Reaction score
394
I wish NBC would go with "ND" guys. Maybe Allen Pinkett or someone like him. I can't stand having Haden in the booth. I just think he likes seeing ND lose (because he's a U$C guy). Go Irish!

Same here. I'd like to see them add Steve Beuerlein to the booth. He said he really enjoyed doing the Navy game last year, and would be very interested in doing more ND games. I also think he did a very good and fair job as well.
 
C

CLEARWALL

Guest
Really? I dont see Hayden as being a homer at all. I think given his background, he's extremely objective during the SC games. Unless yall havent noticed, outside the '05 game, theyve been like 5000x more talented than we were. It's hard to gloss that over.
 
G

GreenNGold

Guest
Really? I dont see Hayden as being a homer at all. I think given his background, he's extremely objective during the SC games. Unless yall havent noticed, outside the '05 game, theyve been like 5000x more talented than we were. It's hard to gloss that over.

Agreed.

As I said earlier in the post, the remaining presence of Pat Haden softens the blow of Hammond not being there.
 

OCIrish

Fukk Michigan
Messages
3,280
Reaction score
218
I would much rather see Tony Roberts than anyone that NBC could find. At least it's not that God awful prick of a former WR Chris Collingsworth. That guy is the biggest tool that ever called a game in College or the NFL.
 
G

GreenNGold

Guest
I would much rather see Tony Roberts than anyone that NBC could find. At least it's not that God awful prick of a former WR Chris Collingsworth. That guy is the biggest tool that ever called a game in College or the NFL.

Amen to Collinsworth-less.

He's, IMO, good in the studio with analysis, but as an announcer, he's pretty bad.
 
S

Sweeney6083

Guest
Hammond was a usc guy and although he was okay , I never liked having as usc guy calling the games.
 
C

CLEARWALL

Guest
Sweeney6083 said:
Hammond was a usc guy and although he was okay , I never liked having as usc guy calling the games.

I think you mean Pat Hayden, who was a QB for the Trojans. Hammond is a U Kentucky grad.
 
Top