Colt Brennan is better than Brady Quinn ...

johnnd05

Johnny T. works for me
Messages
4,522
Reaction score
275
So says the AP:

NEW YORK -- The old Troy Smith was at his best on the run. The new and improved version can sit in the pocket all day and pick apart defenses with his arm.

Smith's evolution from running quarterback to precise passer made No. 1 Ohio State all but unstoppable this season -- and helped him win The Associated Press Player of the Year honor announced Tuesday.

"I am a quarterback," Smith said, "through and through."

There's no doubt about that anymore. In fact, he might be the best to ever play at Ohio State.

The Buckeyes' senior won the AP award about as easily as he won the Heisman Trophy, drawing 59 of 65 first-place votes.

Arkansas tailback Darren McFadden and Hawaii quarterback Colt Brennan tied for a distant second, each receiving two votes from the AP poll voters. Notre Dame quarterback Brady Quinn and West Virginia tailback Steve Slaton each got one vote.

Smith will wrap up his college career against Florida on Jan. 8 in the Tostitos BCS National Championship. He'll try to lead Ohio State (12-0) to its fifth title and first since 2002, the year he arrived on campus in Columbus as part of a heralded recruiting class.

Smith was the last player signed by the Buckeyes that year, recruited more for his speed and strength than his passing ability. Coach Jim Tressel never promised him he'd play quarterback in college.

But Smith was determined and now it's hard to believe there was ever a doubt about whether he could consistently win games with his passing.

"He's gone to work on understanding the game and working on his feet and working on his set depth," Tressel said recently. "All of those type of things -- pre-snap reads, post-snap reads. He's just methodically gotten better every day that he's been here. Watching him in practice today, he was working like a son of a gun trying to get better today. It's fun to watch."

When Smith first got a chance to lead the Buckeyes in 2004, it was his ability to improvise and turn a broken play into a positive one that sparked the Ohio State offense.

In 2005, the Buckeyes implemented a lot of spread-option plays to take advantage of Smith's elusiveness.

The past two seasons, Smith ran 218 times for 950 yards and 13 touchdowns, while completing a more-than-solid 60 percent of his passes.

This season, Smith has run only 62 times for 233 yards and a TD, while completing 67 percent of his throws.

Smith said it's all about preparation and trusting your teammates.

"Everything would have to be credited to my offensive staff, my offensive line, the trust in my offensive line, my receivers doing a great job catching the ball and making plays after they catch the ball, the tailbacks doing a great job in pass protection and then when they get a chance to catch it, making things happen," Smith said. "That's how I developed."

After throwing 24 touchdown passes and seven interceptions in his first two seasons, he threw 30 TDs and only five picks in 2006.

"I hate throwing interceptions," he said. "That's my pet peeve. The person who intercepts it, I want to hit them so hard because I want the ball back.

"Then, once you watch it on film, you see something you could have done better. You know when the play is coming and you rewind it. Every time you watch it, you hope it turns out different."

Smith has one of the best set of receivers in the country at his disposal with Ted Ginn Jr. as the top deep threat, Anthony Gonzalez working the middle of the field and Brian Robiskie and Roy Hall providing high-quality depth.

Tight ends Brian Hartline and Rory Nicol have also gotten into the act, as Smith has masterfully spread the ball around and kept opponents guessing where he will go next.

In his virtuoso performance against No. 2 Michigan to wrap up Ohio State's perfect regular season, Smith passed for 316 yards and four touchdowns, one to each wide receiver, in a 42-39 victory.

"We've got some guys, if we can get them the ball, are a little faster than Troy," Tressel said. "We love it when he runs and all that stuff, but we like it when Teddy runs with the ball and [tailback] Antonio Pittman and Anthony Gonzalez and Brian Robiskie and Brian Hartline and Rory Nicol, and [tailbacks] Mo Wells and Chris Wells. And [Smith] does a nice job of distributing that ball around to a lot of different people."

By learning to make everybody around him better, Smith made himself the best.

Copyright 2006 by The Associated Press
 
T

tchris555

Guest
Colt Brennan is definately much better than Brady Quinn. So is Timmy Chang. Much, much better.

Brady Quinn wouldn't even throw for 8 TD's against Hawaii's schedule and in that offense.
 

marv81s

v v v KamaraPolice's GF
Messages
1,463
Reaction score
66
Colt Brennan is definately much better than Brady Quinn. So is Timmy Chang. Much, much better.

Brady Quinn wouldn't even throw for 8 TD's against Hawaii's schedule and in that offense.

do i detect sarcasm?!

AP is a f'n joke, through and through in every facet. They are a joke news organization and are just a f'n joke all around and this just confirms what I already thought of them.
 

KMac151993

Well-known member
Messages
3,603
Reaction score
2,141
Colt is a great QB and it doesn't really matter where you finish unless its #1 so it doesn't really matter.
 

SillyIrish

New member
Messages
1,020
Reaction score
22
It really doesn't matter where they finish, Colt had a tremendous year although probably against subpar talent. If you want to go by stats then I guess Colt should have won the big one, but we all know why and any reporter worth a grain of salt knows why he wasn't even invited. Don't let these people get under your skin, it's not worth the energy. One final thought, good for Colt to get some recognition he does deserve some acolades, and remember Brady did win the Maxwell.
 

jiggafini19

The Pope
Messages
7,370
Reaction score
58
Colt Brennan will not succeed in any way in the NFL. And what he did in college against Pac 10 schools and bigger competition speaks for itself.
 

southbend62

New member
Messages
229
Reaction score
34
There are many people that would say the same about Brady Quinn. 0-4 versus USC, No bowl wins. Just saying......

Yes they will say that about Brady Quinn...but what pisses off those same people is that he will be first in the NFL draft and have a long and storied career in professional football. And graduate from ND with a double major.

I'll be curious to see what Troy Smith and Colt Brennan do after college...that is if they graduate.
 
J

jerseyborn1971

Guest
There are many people that would say the same about Brady Quinn. 0-4 versus USC, No bowl wins. Just saying......

They will say that, but they'll be wrong. BQ didn't play in the WAC or whatever the hell Hawaii plays in. Take out the Michigan game this year and his performances were pretty solid over the last two years against everybody. I wish Brady would stop being abused because the defense gave up big plays and cost us games.
 

jiggafini19

The Pope
Messages
7,370
Reaction score
58
Brady Quinn is a four year starter at Notre Dame. He's been running an NFL style offense for the last two.

If there are people comparing Quinn to Colt Brennan, they're fucking morons and NFL stands for NOT FOR LONG because that is their job status in The League if they're pushing this crap.

Give me a break.

Brennan is not David Carr or Alex Smith. Not even close. He isn't even Tony Romo.
 
G

goldenechoes

Guest
The hype surrounding Troy Smith is unbelievable.

The guy is a highlight reel and nothing more. This isnt the NBA.
 

jiggafini19

The Pope
Messages
7,370
Reaction score
58
People are underrating him as an NFL QB.

He's QB of the only unbeaten team outside of Boise, Idaho. Some of that hype is probaby deserved.

Personally, I don't think he is the college QB that Vince Young was as a fourth year junior and Smith is a 5th year senior. But he's still good.
 

connor_in

Oh Yeeaah!!!
Messages
11,433
Reaction score
1,006
I think that Brady is probably the better quarterback than Colt and he will have a better NFL career than any other QB coming out this year. I think that he was probably over hyped before the season, then had to overcome mediocre (at best) O-line and defense to try and lead the team to victories. However, in a decent set up in the pros, he could do very well. He definitely has a head start on everyone else since ND runs tha Patriots playbook and I am sure CW has worked him to death on reads.
 
C

claynd105

Guest
Hawaii and Texas Tech quarterbacks are all the same. They put up great stats but don't get drafted anywhere near the first day. They are products of gimmick systems that throw the ball ridiculous amounts. Colt Brennan is fun to watch in college but that will be the only time anyone gets to watch him play in a non preseason game.
 
Top