Manning finalist

[lattedatte]

I think most would agree these are the top 11 QB's, although I think J. Beck got shafted. Interested how you guys would rate them. Keep in mind this is a college award. I will compile the Irish Envy results to see who the winner will be.

Finalists include: Erik Ainge (Tennessee), John David Booty (USC), Colt Brennan (Hawaii), Brian Brohm (Louisville), Chad Henne (Michigan), Chris Leak (Florida), Nate Longshore (California), Brady Quinn (Notre Dame), JaMarcus Russell (LSU), Troy Smith (Ohio State) and Patrick White (West Virginia).

1. Brady
2. Smith
3. Brohm
4. White
5. Brennan
6. Booty
7. Russell
8. Ainge
9. Henne
10. Longshore
11. Leak

 

[Óglaigh_na_hÉireann]

My list would be similar, but Brohm would definitely be at 2 and Smith at 3. Yes, it's a college award, but I think that if Brohm were surrounded by more talent he'd be next to unstoppable.

 

[lattedatte]

My list would be similar, but Brohm would definitely be at 2 and Smith at 3. Yes, it's a college award, but I think that if Brohm were surrounded by more talent he'd be next to unstoppable.

Brohm's a hell of a player, no doubt...

 

[Specnatz]

I would take out Ainge and put in kolb froum Houston. He is very underrated by most college fans but he is getting some notice from scouts for the pros.

 

[LOVEMYIRISH]

I think most would agree these are the top 11 QB's, although I think J. Beck got shafted.

Yeah he did...his stats are phenominal...but he's surrounded but a crappy team.

 

[NDAlumSon]

1
8
2
10
Colt McCoy
3
9
7
4
6
11