Yes, as a lifelong golfer and enthusiast, I do personally believe golf if better without Tiger Woods,for several reasons.
First of all is his relation with the fans.Some will say, "Oh,but he's got his foundation,and does all kinds of stuff for his charities",well that is all just for show....this is a guy who can't stand his fans.It has always been his personality since he came on tour that he wants nothing to do with fans.In the most rare of circumstances will he sign an autograph,and just really doesn't care.I know this from several experiences,from working a tour event,to meeting several tour players and getting their perspectives as well.
Second is his "incident" with his wife.Yes this is a personal problem, but it is a very big problem for golf.If this was the NBA or NFL,it wouldn't be that bad in the eyes of sports fans...but to be honest,this is the gentleman's game,it always has been and always will be.This has been a cancer for the tour for the last 2 years.
And third, I personally feel it's time for the next generation. Even if Tiger were back right now, I still think the new generation of golfers would have no problem overtaking him....however, with Tiger gone, it helps shine the spotlight more on them, instead of still on himself wondering when he'll be back.
Now,I'm not completely against Tiger.He really has done a lot for the game.He really helped bring it back to prominence with his 97' victory at Augusta,and then what else he has done.He is also huge for tv ratings.
Personally...I think he's done for the year....I've thought this for several months now.