Eff the AP

The 2007 Associated Press football All-America teams were announced on Tuesday, and guess what? Notre Dame’s Trevor Laws, who led the nation in tackles from the defensive line positions (and was the only defensive lineman ranked in the top 100, let alone the top 50), isn’t on the first team. No surprise there, though: that sort of honor doesn’t go to a relatively unknown player from a 3-9 football team, even if that team does happen to be Notre Dame. But most of us figured that his spectacular numbers and consistently solid performance on an undertalented defense would land him SOME sort of All-America status: and so what’s genuinely shocking is that Trevor is NOWHERE to be found on ANY of the three All-America teams.

[UPDATE: He's also not a first- or second-teamer, nor is he even one of the NINE defensive linemen who receives an honorable mention, on the Sports Illustrated AA list. So eff them, too.]

To give you a sense of the craziness of this, here’s a comparison of Laws’s 2007 statistics with the players who made the AP’s AA squads over him - I’ve included both defensive ends and defensive tackles (first-teamers in yellow, seconds in green, thirds in blue), since Laws played a sort of “tweener” role in the 3-4:

So there you have it folks. If the fiasco of last year’s Heisman “race” wasn’t enough for you, here’s some hard evidence that postseason awards are MEANINGLESS indicators of the quality of one’s on-the-field play.

Lest I be accused of being just another whiny homer making a case for his own guy, let me be clear that I felt very much the same way - and seem to recall saying as much - when Tom Zbikowski was named a second-team All-American after the 2006 season. That was all about hype and name recognition, and had basically nothing to do with what Zibby had and (mostly) hadn’t done on the football field that year. Is the snubbing of Laws a matter of just desserts for the overexposure of Notre Dame football in years past? Maybe. But it’s really a shame to see a season like the one that Trevor had this year go so wholly unnoticed on the national scene, ESPECIALLY given the less-than-ideal circumstances (you know, 3-9 record, historically awful offensive ineptitude, and so on) that surrounded it.

Congratulations to all the guys who made the AA teams. Obviously they had really good seasons, and deserved some serious recognition. It’s just a shame that Laws wasn’t able to get his due.

Tags: , ,

Leave a Reply